Photographer's Note
I know I'm three days late for the anniversary of 9/11, but in my defense, I've been insanely busy preparing to move next week to Calgary. Better a late tribute than none, I suppose.
The thirteenth anniversary didn't generate quite the headlines that the tenth anniversary did, but for those of us who were alive at the time--particularly we Americans--we'll remember just as vividly on the 54th or 73rd anniversary. I took this picture in May during my visit to the 9/11 memorial. Nothing special about the picture technically, but the subject is sacred.
Looking at this picture, I was reminded of words I jotted down into my journal in a brief burst of inspiration on the 10th anniversary of the attacks. I had been watching coverage of the commemorations and reliving again the horror and anguish of that fateful day. But one thing affected me even more than the 10-year old footage. I'm not in the habit of getting particularly personal on TE, but here's what I wrote:
Looking at photos of the ceremony, I couldn’t help but be struck by the family members standing or kneeling in front of the names of those killed in the attacks. I found it both captivating and heart-wrenching that these grieving people, bereft of the physical and emotional presence of their family members, reached out to the names on the memorial. Touching them, running their fingers across them, tracing them, mourning them. The unique names, 2,977 of them. Just two or three or maybe four words each, representing in that brief space a truncated lifetime of joy, discouragement, triumph, setbacks, dreams, and fears. Combinations of just 20 to 30 letters each—but portals to memories of family events, friendships, service, love, and grieving. Those names, each representing the center node of a network of hundreds of lives that were forever touched for having known the person the name represents—and forever shattered for having that person taken so soon from their lives. All of this, represented in two or three proper nouns that came to represent a human life and now act as a proxy in its absence...
...I fear that the same thing will happen with the events of September 11 that has happened with Pearl Harbor. I worry that as the focus shifts from telling the stories of those who died and those who survived and where we were and what we were doing when we heard, to a more summary-level textbook history discussion—I worry that future generations will learn little more about the attacks than that 4 jetliners were hijacked, 2 crashed into the World Trade Center, 1 into the Pentagon, and 1 in a field in Pennsylvania; that 2,977 people lost their lives; that the hijackers were terrorists; and that the attacks sparked a War on Terror. And nothing else. All of those statements are facts, but they sound so sterile, so devoid of sentiment, so clinical. Whatever else 9/11 was, it was not an event that allowed any American to be emotionally detached from its terror and tragedy, especially not those who lost loved ones.
I want my children and their children to know what a horrific, numbing, and world-shattering event it was. We had grown up in the Reagan and the Clinton years—no major wars, no lasting economic disasters, perhaps some knowledge of atrocities in the world in Rwanda, East Germany, and other places, but nothing like that in our own lives. This was the United States of America—things like that just didn’t happen here. How naïve we were. How wonderfully sheltered and horribly deluded to think that suffering was the common lot of all mankind not born in the USA. It’s become a cliché to say that everything changes after a major tragedy, but its triteness doesn’t diminish its truthfulness. Everything about our worldview changed.
I'll never forget.
aliabazari, Royaldevon, timecapturer, worldcitizen, jean113 has marked this note useful
Critiques | Translate
Royaldevon
(86564) 2014-09-15 0:53 [Comment]
timecapturer
(49288) 2014-09-15 3:36
Hello Clark
with the world in turmoil once again and terrorism a real threat to our lives, taking time to remember the horror of that day seems all the more compelling and appropriate, but it passed here in the UK with very little attention, sadly.
I did post my own tribute here on TE, but that too attracted very little comment. I read your notes and also thoughts on the 10th anniversary and have to agree with them.
I always imagined a world without conflict and hatred once the Cold War ended and yet now we seem to be drifting back into that sort of world once again. I cannot fathom out why - and no politician seems able to inspire me with the confidence that it is resolvable.
Beautiful and touching tribute image..............
Have a good week - B.
Good luck with the move too! B.
worldcitizen
(16234) 2014-09-15 13:41 [Comment]
Photo Information
-
Copyright: Clark Monson (cdmonson)
(5304)
- Genre: ÌÅÑÒÀ
- Medium: ÖÂÅÒÍÎÉ
- Date Taken: 2014-05-27
- Categories: ÖÅÐÅÌÎÍÈß, ÑÎÁÛÒÈÅ
- Camera: Canon 6D, Canon EF 24-105mm f/4 L IS USM, Digital ISO 100, B+W 72mm Circular Polarizer
- Exposure: f/4, 1/125 ñåêóíä
- More Photo Info: view
- Âåðñèÿ: Îðèãèíàëüíàÿ âåðñèÿ, Workshop
- Date Submitted: 2014-09-14 21:58